In my opinion, this was the right choice. Wilson, like everyone else on earth, was not perfect. He is best known as the 38th U.S. President, who helped found the League of Nations, and also received a Nobel Prize. But it is also true that he supported and encouraged segregation. However, nobody would argue that Wilson is being honored at Princeton for his racism. That was a flaw in his personality that we can justly criticize. But to allow this flaw to overwrite and erase all the good he did is, in my opinion, taking things too far. If we start doing that, where will it end?
|Charles Lindbergh & his plane, 1927|
But there is a dark side to this story. Lindbergh was also a Nazi sympathizer and an antisemite -- a fact that was recently well-documented in the PBS American Experience segment, Fallen Hero: Charles Lindbergh in the 1940s. In 1936, Lindbergh visited Nazi Germany and was so impressed with the country's industry and revitalized economy that by 1938 he and his family were making plans to move to Berlin. Also in 1938, Lindbergh was awarded the Service Cross of the German Eagle for his contributions to aviation -- presented by Hermann Goering on behalf of the Fuehrer. Lindbergh became so convinced that Hitler would inevitably win the war, he advocated for America to follow an isolationist policy and stay out of it. And he blamed the Jews for getting us into it.
As a Jew myself, I most certainly do find this side of Lindbergh offensive. But I do not feel "unsafe" in the Lindbergh Terminal because of it. Nor do I advocate erasing his name from our history or renaming the terminal.* As with Wilson, Lindbergh is not being honored for his racism. I see him as a genius in one area, and a flawed human being in other areas.
Insisting that historical figures of the past must stand up to the scrutiny of 21st-century values is a very slippery slope. For that matter, a lot of modern heroes don't measure up in every way, either. If we insist that all of our heroes be absolutely perfect, then we shall soon have no role models at all. Sometimes it is necessary, as Rabbi Meir in the Talmud once said, to keep the kernel and throw away the chaff.
* * *
*Although in a way it was renamed, as Terminal 1, because apparently out-of-state people could not distinguish between the Lindbergh Terminal and the Humphrey Terminal and got lost. But apparently they can tell the difference between 1 and 2. As of this writing, there is currently a movement to rename Lindbergh Terminal-1 after Prince: see http://minnesota.cbslocal.com/2016/04/22/msp-terminal-prince-petition/
* * *
See also my Nov 20, 2017 article, Franken's Apology: A Jewish Perspective, which explores the question of repentance and forgiveness for flawed leaders (and the rest of us, too.).