When I suggest to fellow Hasidim that we should no longer use chickens for kapporos, the most common answer I get is this:
"The Holy Ari did it with a chicken; the Baal Shem Tov did it with a chicken; the Rebbe did it with a chicken -- and weren't they holy people? So why do you say it is wrong now?"
The 7th Lubavitcher Rebbe making kapporos |
Yes
it is true that many of our greatest rabbis and teachers did kapporos with a
chicken. But they also treated the chickens
with care and respect.
They understood that chickens are living beings with feelings. It is said that when the Holy Baal Shem Tov, founder of Hasidism, sharpened his knife, he moistened the stone with his own tears. (Shivchei Ha-Besht) Our religion acknowledges that Eden was vegetarian, and that in an ideal world, this is what we would all be. But this world is not Eden. Eating meat was a necessity in Old Russia and Ukraine in the 1700s. Before the days of year-round fresh veggies flown in from everywhere, being a healthy vegetarian was virtually impossible in northern climates. So the Torah does permit slaughter. But the Baal Shem Tov at least felt deep sadness that something had to die in order for the people to live.
They understood that chickens are living beings with feelings. It is said that when the Holy Baal Shem Tov, founder of Hasidism, sharpened his knife, he moistened the stone with his own tears. (Shivchei Ha-Besht) Our religion acknowledges that Eden was vegetarian, and that in an ideal world, this is what we would all be. But this world is not Eden. Eating meat was a necessity in Old Russia and Ukraine in the 1700s. Before the days of year-round fresh veggies flown in from everywhere, being a healthy vegetarian was virtually impossible in northern climates. So the Torah does permit slaughter. But the Baal Shem Tov at least felt deep sadness that something had to die in order for the people to live.
Now
look around you at the kapporos centers.
Is anybody weeping for the deaths of the chickens like the Holy Baal
Shem Tov did?
Probably not. I have been laughed at and ridiculed by fellow Hasidim for saying that chickens have feelings. One heckler even asked, "Do you really think chickens are smart enough to know what is happening to them?" Yes, I do. Modern research shows that chickens have an intelligence level at least as high as that of a three or four year old child. Think about that next time you see a pre-schooler or bounce your own child on your knee. That child is certainly aware enough to suffer pain, hunger, and fear of death. And so is a chicken. The Baal Shem Tov understood this. His modern followers do not.
Yes, it is also true that the Holy Ari also did it with a chicken back in the 1500s. But he, too, was sensitive to the suffering of animals. Consider the following story:
It happened one day in Sfat,
Israel, that Rabbi Isaac Luria, the great kabbalist known as the Holy Ari (Ari-Hakodesh),
ordered one of his students to leave him immediately. The student felt terrible.
What sin had he committed to deserve this? All that day he wept and prayed to G-d that his sins should not
keep him banished from his Rebbe’s presence.
The next morning he
came to the Holy Ari and begged to be told what wrong he had done. The Holy Ari said,” It is because of your
chickens. Three days now they have been
without food. They cried out to HaShem
and because of this, you have been under a ban (karet) from Heaven. Now, if you promise to feed your chickens
even before your morning prayers, I will loosen the ban on you.” The student promised to do so, and the ban
was lifted. (From Shivchei Ha-Ari)
From this we learn how much HaShem our Creator, Who
“has compassion for all the creatures,” cares about the suffering of
chickens. The student’s sin was tzaar
baalei chayyim, cruelty to animals.
The cries of those starving chickens were canceling out his Torah
learning and banning his prayers from reaching Heaven.
Those are NOT the sounds of happy birds, they are NOT singing in joy at "helping us do a mitzvah," as some people have been taught to believe. You are hearing the anguished cries that chickens make when they are in fear and pain. Last year (2013) thousands of chickens in New York kapporos centers died of thirst and hunger during a prolonged heat wave. In previous years, chickens that were not sold by the eve of Yom Kippur were abandoned in warehouses. There they spent our most holy day of repentance slowly dying of neglect. Again, recall the story of the Ari and the chickens above. How is this any different?
Are those sad cries rising to Heaven and canceling out your Torah and mitzvot, Heaven forbid? Even worse, are they canceling out the prayers of the whole Jewish community?
This is a very serious question. We are taught in kabbalah that when we use the things of this world -- mineral, vegetable, or animal -- for serving God, then we elevate the Holy Sparks (netzotzot) within those things and effect a tikkun olam -- a repair of the universe. This is a classic Hasidic teaching, we find it in the writings of all our Rebbes, starting with the Baal Shem Tov himself.
But the reverse is also true: If we do not use the material world with holiness and respect, the sparks are not raised, and we drag the world down. Rebbe Nachman of Breslov said that if shechitah (kosher slaughter) is not performed correctly and with the proper kavannah (focused intention), then the sparks are not elevated, and we absorb negativity (klippot) from the life-force of the animal. (See Likutei Moharan #37).
Combined with the story of the Ari above, I interpret this to mean not only the actual moment of slaughter must be proper, but also how the chickens are treated beforehand. I am pretty sure that Rebbe Nachman would not have approved of using today's abused, starving chickens.
So we must indeed ask ourselves: Is the mistreatment of chickens at today's kapporos centers elevating sparks, or is it blocking our prayers from reaching Heaven?
Portrait of Rabbi Israel ben Eliezer, the Baal Shem Tov |
So: Would the Baal Shem Tov be able to enter today's kapporos centers? Or would his entry be blocked by dead prayers that do not rise upward to Heaven?
Today we have hardened our hearts to the suffering of God’s creatures. Kapporos chickens are crammed into small cages, shipped for miles in open trucks, stacked for days in hot warehouses without any food or water, then handled roughly like cheap merchandise. People stand around gossiping, while they carelessly hold the chickens by the wings as if they were nothing but shopping bags. Dangling them this way is very painful for the bird, and can result in torn muscles and ligaments in the wings, because a chicken's wings are not strong enough to support its body weight.
This gross disrespect for living things is NOT the way our ancestors held chickens in the past. All of the old drawings I have seen show the chickens being held upright by the legs, or supporting the body with their hands, as the Lubavitcher Rebbe is doing in the picture above. This dangling them by the wings is a modern cruelty learned, most likely, from the factory farm industry. (I have seen gentile farmers doing this.)
Such cruelty does not elevate the Holy Sparks! It drags us down into sin. You cannot commit a sin to do a mitzvah!
Or a minhag, for that matter. Any validity the ceremony might have had in the past is canceled out by the cruelty to the chickens in modern times. Precisely because of how the chickens are transported and sold nowadays, many rabbis recommend using money instead.
In addition, there is the issue of waste. In the past, people often gave their kapporos chicken to
a poor family as tsedakah (charity). This charity was part of the kapporos ritual, it
completed the tikkun.
"Repentence, prayer, and charity avert the evil decree."
"Repentence, prayer, and charity avert the evil decree."
Bags of dead kapporos chickens in garbage truck, 2013 |
That violates the prohibition against needlessly wasting something (bal tashchit). Last year, under several news articles about how these chickens were ending up in the city dump, there were numerous comments asking: "Why didn't they give them to the homeless shelters? Or the local soup lines?" Such blatant waste of food while people go hungry is a shanda, a public disgrace that reflects badly on the Jewish people. Here there are people going hungry, and we throw the chickens in the dump? Where is the holiness in that?
Sickly, injured chickens crammed in a cage, waiting to be used for kapporos. These are not the happy free-range chickens our ancestors used. |
As our Sages teach us, the world is like a set of scales. Every good deed tips the world to the side of good, and every sin tips it to the side of evil, heaven forbid.
Is the cruelty in today's kapporos centers canceling out our prayers on Yom Kippur? Is it adding to the burden of sin in the world?
Again, these are serious questions. Giving money to charity instead of using a chicken eliminates all these questions of cruelty and kashrut. You can avoid absorbing negative klippah energy into your life and that of your family. You can be sure that the monetary value of the chicken really is going to the poor and not to the city dump. You can be more certain that your prayers are not being blocked from rising to Heaven. You can be sure you are making a real tikkun -- the act of charity that averts the evil decree -- and not contributing to the burden of sin in the world.
For all these reasons, I feel it is time for us to stop using chickens for kapporos and give money instead. May you have an easy fast, and may you be sealed for a good new year!
* * *
I have written a condensed one-page printable version of this article, suitable for a flyer or small poster. Download the PDF here. Feel free to print and hand it out, adding your own local contact info at the bottom.
See also: Kapporos Chickens don't Sing! -- my 2013 article on the misconceptions about chickens that you may hear at kapporos centers, etc.
* * *
To learn more about this issue, get my new book, just out on June 4: Kapporos Then and Now: Toward a More Compassionate Tradition available on Lulu.com. Neither a vegetarian manifesto nor a "Torah-True" religious tract, I approach the issue as a combination of theologian, cultural anthropologist, and participatory journalist, offering numerous reasons why using money is a better option today -- but also critiquing both sides for both their strong and weak points. WARNING: Whether you are for or against using chickens as Kapporos, this book requires an open mind to read.